Author: Kenya West

  • Dear Mr President, It’s Nothing Personal, We’re Taking Back Our Country From Wolves of Jubilee

    Dear Mr President, It’s Nothing Personal, We’re Taking Back Our Country From Wolves of Jubilee



    Throughout history the power of the people has been tested time and again. Kenya’s own struggle for independence has pride of place in the annals of freedom struggles. Our progenitors turned the clock of history when they could no longer bear the yoke of colonial oppression. They gave us the promise of a fresh lease of life in a land splendor where justice would be our shield and defender.
    The promise of our national anthem has however been betrayed with impunity. Where the fruit of our labour should fill every heart with thanks giving, our nation has become a looters’ paradise.
    In March 2015, President Uhuru Kenyatta restored our hope when he declared ā€œan unwavering war against corruption,ā€ in his second State of the Nation Address. He received a standing ovation from the joint houses of Parliament. The rest of Kenyans beamed with unguarded delight. Yet, does all this seem to have been no more than perfectly choreographed hot air?
    As a trusting citizen, I feel cheated. As a nation, our values have not merely been altered, but have actually been destroyed. High level government officers have made runaway graft and corruption the order of the day. They shamelessly exploit the toil of hardworking Kenyans and present carefully constructed defense lies.
    The state has been quick to repudiate the vice while laying claim to it. The doublethink trend is agonizing. As it consciously induces unconsciousness, millions of Kenyans can only afford a meal per day. Not by choice, but as a result of economic paralysis triggered by a few upper crusts.
    Mr President, enough of the historical decadence and polysyllabic speeches. Kenya is waiting for you to take a stand and emulate one Lee Kuan Yew whom you are on record as stating he is your role model. The founding father of Singapore transformed his country from a mere trading post to the present day Asian metropolis that it is. We are waiting for you to be our Lee Kuan Yew, for the future and unborn generations.
    Kenya is smarting under the burden of the Health Sandal, Land grabbing, CCTV installation, NYS non fictional soap opera, Youth Fund, Anglo ā€œfleecingā€ 3Billion payout reward, irregular tendering, billions that remain unaccounted in government departments, among many more economic crimes by the high and mighty.
    Public anger is mounting, as can only be expected. History has taught us that the power inherent in the will of ordinary citizens has birthed new dawns.
    At the end of the 17th century, peasants in France redesigned their country’s political landscape to bring a rotten monarchy to its end. Royal coffers had been depleted under King Louis XVI and his predecessors. The people’s plight fell on deaf ears. The old order got its death certificate.
    The constitutional power bestowed unto Kenyans demand for accountability and transparency in all state affairs. At no point should favoritism apply to anyone who has consciously defiled our economy. You must take an intrepid stand
    Women, the old and the youth are dying daily from treatable conditions. Unemployment is soaring at an all time high. A majority wallow in hopelessness due to the billions lost through scams. Money that could have helped in the alleviation of the basic living standards.
    We must reclaim our loving country from tainted leadership.
    We the electorate doesn’t want to overthrow the Government as one spin doctor and his handlers put it. We just want to take control of our destiny, that we may be culpable if we mess up. Our hopes, passion and vision for the future are our very own existence.

    Written by
    Nancy Wambui

    Political Ā Communications Expert based in Ā South Africa

    This article expresses the author’s opinion only. The views and opinions expressed here do not necessarily represent those of Kenya Insights or its Editors. We welcome opinion and views on topical issues. Email: [email protected]

  • Controversies: How Wafula Chebukati Made It To IEBC Top Job And Why Jubilee Is Uncomfortable With CEO Ezra Chiloba

    Controversies: How Wafula Chebukati Made It To IEBC Top Job And Why Jubilee Is Uncomfortable With CEO Ezra Chiloba

     

    Controversy has hit the IEBC nominees by the President. A nine-member team headed by Bernadette Musundi will meet at an undisclosed location Tuesday morning, amid growing criticism it failed to scrutinize and give perfect candidates the green light.

    IEBC Chairman nominee Wafula Chebukati has had many eyebrows raised with questions stuck around his nominations which weren’t awarded on merits. Several controversies that questions Wafula’s integrity has been forthcoming and was, he was the lawyer to former anti-graft chief Philip Kinisu who settled on to pick office for allegedly pocketing Sh35 million from the National Youth Service. There are concerns that Chebukati could come from a beneficiary of the cash, although there is no evidence yet.

    It doesn’t end therean active IEBC Chair nominee is a half brother to Kinisu who is married to Nancy Gitau’s sister. Nancy Gitau is one of the most powerful women in Jubilee administration, and we learn she’s top organs in Statehouse controlling the billion shilling campaign kitty for the 2017 elections.

    Chebukati’s law firm – Cootow and Associates Advocates – is also accused of professional negligence that led to a loss of millions of shillings belonging to the Nairobi county government. The firm did not defend a suit filed by Salima Enterprises against the county and the county government lost the case and was forced to pay Sh325 million compensation in addition to the cost of the suit and legal fees.

    On December 23, the selection panel settled on Chebukati, alongside High Court advocate Tukero ole Kina for IEBC chairman. Kina scored 77 per cent against Chebukati’s 63 per cent. But President Uhuru Kenyatta – allowed by law to pick the electoral commission chairman from a list of two – pulled a surprise on Kenyans by settling on the less qualified Chebukati, who coincidentally comes from the same region as IEBC chief executive Ezra Chiloba.

    The other candidate for IEBC commissioner with fresh integrity questions is Consolata Nkatha. She allegedly has an active criminal court case, in which she is accused of defrauding the Museums of Kenya of Sh280 million.

    There are genuine concerns that IEBC CEO Ezra Chiloba and chairperson nominee Wafula Chebukati cannot work concurrently for the commission because they are from the same community and county are misplaced.

    Kenya Insights gathers that Statehouse power brokers are uncomfortable with Ezra holding the CEO position vowing to send him packing through several avenues including forced resignation. Word is he’s been approached to quote a price for his exit. The unease is fuelled by the fact that is dating Rosemary Odinga, and they fear this could give Odinga an upper hand. They’re now looking into replacing him with their trusted candidate. The behind-the-scenes innuendos go to show the greater influence by the executive in the IEBC line-up something that casts queries on the credibility and sovereign independence of the electoral body given the powerful external influences.

    Wafula according to power shots is seen as System’s friendly and ‘easy to work with’. He’s a known close associate to DP Ruto whom he met several days to his appointment in Mombasa. The appointment has political bait as Well, the appointment of Chebukati and former Anglican Church Archbishop Eliud Wabukala to head the anti-graft agency are meant to woo the Bukusu community to support Jubilee. Bukusu commands about 600,000 votes. It’s not by coincidence that Kinisu a Bukusu has been replaced by Wabukhala, his tribe mate as the EACC Chairman.

  • Doctors Strike: Uhuru’s Regime End Game Is To Kill Public Healthcare For Private Healthcare With Politicians Investing In Medicare

    Doctors Strike: Uhuru’s Regime End Game Is To Kill Public Healthcare For Private Healthcare With Politicians Investing In Medicare

     

    The doctor’s strike is getting into it’s 5th week with a total public healthcare freeze throughout the country and the administration stuck in cat and rat games with doctors leaving the poor Kenyans to keep burying their loved ones. The majority of Kenyans given poverty index are reliant on public health services and a closure of the same quickly translates into investments nation.

    Doctors have stood their grounds of 100% implementation of the CBA that the government signed but have taken a turn around to dishonour. Apart from 300% salary increase, the CBA have with it beneficial cranes that would spruce the medical state in public hospitals. These include; More doctors to be employed to ensure more access by the public. The necessary drugs, medical supplies & equipment to serve Kenyans better. Better Remuneration of Doctors – More doctors available all the time at a public hospital near you (Less brain drain regarding doctors leaving for greener pastures).

    With an open laxity and feet dragging by the government to end the doctors strike. A theory being advanced into factual state indicates that the doctors might have played into the hands of the system’s prayers. Prolonging the strike, demonizing the doctors while painting public healthcare as mediocre giving private providers a milestone in the market.

    Khawar Mann of the Abraaj Group, an investment firm based in Dubai that specializes in developing markets, saw something else while at the Metropolitan Hospital in Nairobi, Told NYT in an interview that ā€œNairobi is a sweet spot for us,ā€ he said. ā€œYou have emerging middle incomes. And there is a massive need for health care.ā€ Just when Jubilee got into power, President Uhuru presided over a 2B ground breaking of a modernised Nairobi Hospital Ā health facility with the then CEO and now a CS, Dr.Mailu. First lady Margaret also presided over several alike projects. It was indeed a wet dream expecting Mailu handpicked from the exploitative private healthcare world to perform miracles in streamlining public healthcare instead of advancing the corporate health agendas. No wonder he’s less committed in bringing to an end the crisis.

    Below screenshots of article on Statehouse website that has since been deleted reporting on First Lady launching yet another Private Hospital advancement.

    screenshot_20161231-094633

    screenshot_20161231-094645

    screenshot_20161231-094702

    As Ahmed Tawakal a Health Management expert notes, the scheme is to kill the public healthcare system in the long run. He goes that The current impasse between doctors and the government over the implementation of the 2013 collective bargaining agreement (CBA) may seem like a normal industrial action that is taking longer to resolve. But at its core the lack of effort to stop the deterioration of services in government health facilities due to the strike should have alarm bells ringing as to the potential for complete collapse of the public health system.

    There has been a slow but steady investment in healthcare by several multinational companies and even investment by proxy by the IMF through the International Financial Corporation(IFC).The aim of the investment by the multinationals and venture capitalists is maximizing profits in the chosen ventures. This investment can only have maximum returns if a greater proportion of the population utilize the services of the for-profit healthcare providers and a nudge towards this can only come from the inaction to solving an industrial dispute pitting doctors and government run facilities.

    The resulting vacuum generated by such inaction will result in an acceptability of greater privatization of even essential services that are currently available in public hospitals. Several private equity firms have in the recent past made in-roads in acquiring local stakes in local medical facilities such as Metropolitan Hospital, Goodlife pharmacy chains, and health insurance companies. These investments and also in for-profit social franchising models targeted towards the low-income communities of the slums and rural areas will be the greatest beneficiaries of a collapsed. Non-Welfare health system.

    The returns from greater private insurance coverage, greater uptake of private services and increased importation of pharmaceutical and medical equipment shall tilt the curve to benefit repatriation of profits.
    The government will almost robotically be willing to go along with the experiment as it will be rid of the high payroll expense of doctors and specialists who would be expected to join the consortiums that will be formed to protect their interests. This will reduce the government expenditure on health as a percentage of GDP well below 3% and ensure absorption of the difference by more politically expedient causes.

    The government will even go to the extent of marketing a pro-poor medical insurance scheme under NHIF in the guise that it would reduce financial burden through pooling of resources and would allow the bottom of the pyramid (slum dwellers) to access care at the social health franchises after an enrolment fee and a few other jargon that will be added to confuse them. The new system will almost certainly be touted as a success based on a successful US or Indian model. What won’t be divulged is that the US healthcare system has the worst per capita efficiency and quality of care among OECD countries.

    With this information, all will proceed so fast that we will find ourselves with a predominantly private health system modeled on the US system. The system will, however, be a success to the shareholders and venture capitalists that will get maximum returns on investment. Already there are counties that have had initial contact and alliances with private healthcare entities to set up base in their areas, allocated huge chunks of land to the private healthcare providers and thus it’s only a matter of time before the process is full completed and the vision realized.

    The desperation of the doctors and need to succeed in their chosen field will also force them to either join the growing private care provision or force them to seek greener pastures in foreign lands. Either ways its win-win for the private system and a great loss for the country.

    My plea is that we reform our health system to have a more robust, resilient public health system with sustainable healthcare financing model that does not take us the United States way. Several studies including some from The Commonwealth Fund have found that public, tax-funded health systems have ensured greater access to care for the populace and better outcomes than other systems.

    Studies have also shown that a dollar spent on healthcare by the government has an impact in raising the GDP of that country. Therefore we need a re-think of leadership and governance of health system in the country and entrust it to individuals and structures that cater for the greater good and ensure equitable, sustainable, affordable and quality care to all. The British created the National Health Trust (NHS) from the ashes of World War II and it’s a model we could borrow a leaf from taking into consideration local variation and shortcomings of the NHS.

  • Educational Milestone As KCSE 2016 Results Record Zero Cheating Cases, Here’s How CS Matiang’i Closed Down Every Cheating Loophole

    Educational Milestone As KCSE 2016 Results Record Zero Cheating Cases, Here’s How CS Matiang’i Closed Down Every Cheating Loophole

     

    Kenya is yet to come to terms with the KCSE results announced by Education CS revealing a massive drop in performances as compared to the previous years. Most shocking is that only 15% of the 577K candidates who sat for the exams scored C+ and above meaning 85% of the candidates failed. Such disturbing stats. Going further, only 141 candidates scored straight As down from 2865 the previous year. The embarrassing decline exposed an alarming trend within the system that dubious grades have been churned over time. On releasing the results, the CS said the exam was tightly supervised than ever before with no single cheating case, and for the first time in Kenya history, KNEC didn’t cancel a single result. As the CS said the grades released were the clear and genuine reflection of the candidates and Kenya education system. Damned!

    The inconsistency is attributed to exams cheating which has been rampant in the past recent years, 2015 exams were largely leaked that ministry contemplated calling for the exams. 5000 results were canceled, and it recorded highest numbers of As. Dishonest grades that have seen a culture of jelly students registering for prestigious courses in universities given their strong but untrue grades, shifting courses over the years. Prof. Magoha noted with concern how 50% of students who join medical schools come with fake grades only to spring out of the course when the tough hits the rail.

    Schools and students have been running monkey businesses for good grades that the stiff Matiang’i rules killed embarrassing schools like Kabarak who previously recorded 212 As in 2015 and managed mere 2 As this year. It’s known that of some private schools operate multiple examination centers with an aim of engaging in unethical practices meant to enable them to record favourable rankings in national usual. This is a ridiculous examination malpractice since the proprietors of these schools are apparently using innocent students in an unscrupulous marketing exercise of their businesses.

    Students during exams
    Students during exams

    As it were, these schools register weaker pupils at sister ā€œsatelliteā€ examination centres so as not to bring down the mean scores of their main ā€œmarketingā€ schools. We have discovered that the majority of these schools that offload ā€œweakerā€ pupils usually have a small candidature of between 20 and 30 of their best candidates. These abnormal centers are the ones that top charts whenever ranking for schools is done. How just did the ministry cap exams cheating and beating the cartel at their own game?

    In May 2016, Matiang’i banned the holding of mass prayers and school visiting days during the third term, noting that some unscrupulous individuals use these days to sneak materials that could compromise national exams.

    October, Education Principal Secretary Belio Kipsang announced the overseeing of the national examinations by county commissioners, as opposed to the Kenya National Examination Officials (KNEC) supervisors who had been conducting the similar role in previous national examinations.

    The Education Ministry had also advocated the installation of security cameras in examination centers, aside from preventing the use of mobile phones by invigilators, supervisors or candidates in the exam room.

    Matiang’i made head teachers directly responsible for their exam centres. Under the new regulations, head teachers were required to pick exam papers from county distribution points at 5:00am every day – a departure from normal practice where police managed distribution.

    Exam papers had unique watermark barcodes on each page, a measure that was aimed at curbing copying. Exams marking were done under great scrutiny and set timelines. On the close of business day, all results from marking centers were electronically live streamed to the nerve center for keying in. All markings were done by 24th Dec. Unlike previous times where releasing results was delayed till February a period which gave time for money to exchange hands and manipulate the results, Matiangi released the results almost immediately to cut off this cartel.

    Many useful lessons can be drawn from the successful administration of the 2016 national examinations. The most significant, however, is that with effective collaboration and coordination amongst relevant agencies of government, virtually any national task and objectives of government can be met. Going forward. Therefore, the Ministry of Education will endeavor to ensure effective cooperation and collaboration with all relevant actors to reform and strengthen the education system adequately.

    The second lesson we learn is that the Government has all the machinery and capacity to run a clean, transparent and credible national examination. All we need is careful planning and committed staff who operate with high levels of integrity. Excuses like that of ICT CS Mucheru of Al Shabaab hacking Electronic voting system in favor of manual backup, don’t get things done instead action does.

  • Grand Scheme: How Uhuru is Simply Trapping Raila into His Comfort Zone The Electronic Voting System And Will Beat Him Hands Down

    Grand Scheme: How Uhuru is Simply Trapping Raila into His Comfort Zone The Electronic Voting System And Will Beat Him Hands Down

     

    By Nicholas Olambo
    The political journey of Raila Odinga should be a series of harsh lessons, but has he learned enough? He has been detained and exiled, but he never gave up, he championed the second liberation force and had given a shot at the presidency three times, losing, being rigged out and losing/ being rigged out.

    He still has his eyes set on the prize, but folks have been writing stories describing him as a contender left with ā€˜one bullet,’ 2017 is his do or die contest, but these are illusions he has refuted. He says he is well prepared with more a single ā€˜bullet’ should he be nominated to fly the opposition flag. As things stand Raila is the possible opposition candidate with polls rating the incumbent President Uhuru Kenyatta ahead of him.

    Odinga was beaten by President Uhuru in 2013; he challenged the results at the Supreme Court, but the court’s verdict maintained the status quo. He respected the court’s ruling and moved on keeping a keen check on Jubilee administration, revealing all mega corruption scandals that have rocked President Kenyatta’s leadership. It’s now a see through administration poked with corruption holes all over, from the infamous NYS scandal, Eurobond, Youth Fund and 5 billion Afya House scandal among others. It’s said to be the most corrupt in Kenyan history.

    Odinga has managed to make corruption his key campaign agenda to discredit the Kenyatta led Jubilee administration, and with 2017 just seven months away, the numbers seem likely to tilt for the opposition but will Kenyatta sit back and go in history as a one-term president? Beating incumbents in Africa are ā€˜a miracle.’

    Political analyst/jubilee strategist Mutahi Ngunyi who was the brainchild of ā€˜tyranny of numbers myth’ through which Uhuruto twisted the ICC narrative and rallied their large tribes to win 2013 polls is now singing a different song. With the fast shaping NASA, a united front through which opposition leaders may challenge President Kenyatta, Ngunyi says the myth is no longer viable. NASA is more like NARC in 2002, an unbeatable force.

    In fact soon after Kenyatta assumed office in 2013, Ngunyi described Mr. Kenyatta as a greenhorn president, but I think Kenyatta is ā€˜a tactical and smart’ fellow. He his trapping Mr. Odinga in his comfort zone and will ā€˜beat’ him hands down. The recent chaotic special sittings were deliberate; Uhuru may not even sign the draconian election bill into law. Already there is enough pressure on him from the opposition and religious leaders asking him to rise beyond party interests and reject the controversial draft law.

    The cord is already bracing the country for street protests in January should the bill be signed. The opposition has described the laws as a ploy by Jubilee to rig the coming polls. In 2013, Cord claimed that Jubilee stole elections by hacking IEBC systems and altered results for TNA’s Uhuru Kenyatta. Mr. Odinga can’t substantiate this well; their evidence was rejected by the Supreme Court as huge and time bad.

    Raila is claiming that they will not allow elections rigged but what will he do if he can’t substantiate how he was ā€˜beaten’ in 2013? The same technique will be used on him again; I doubt if he’s determined to keep the check on his competitor’s digital rigging tricks. We are in a digital era, and Jubilee is known to be pro digital. Any schemes to revert to a manual system are deliberate moves to trap Odinga to reject the manual backup system, so they all go digital and ā€˜beat’ him there. If anything Baba is used to being ā€˜beaten,’ he will accept and move on.

    In the last elections, the opposition accused Jubilee of working with hackers and Safaricom who operated the servers to manipulate polls. From them how prepared is CORD to repel and expose such schemes should they arise. Grapevine has it that the State has constituted the group of sharp IT gurus drawn from local universities, Russia, and Chinese computer wizards to do the 2017 dirty jobs.

    While these remain mere speculations, we know the miles player at hand can go. CORD must or by now should’ve hit the computer wizardry world to shop for the brightest minds to monitor the system from their center to detect at the slightest chance any mischievous move during polls. Electronic voters identification is a blessing to CORD and a nightmare to Jubilee who are accused to be scheming on using dead voters to push up their numbers given unfavorable current voters register dynamics. All parties must be at alert IEBC must give nothing short of free, fair, credible, verifiable, tamper-proof, healthy elections. End of discussion!

  • Governor Isaac Rutto  Assaults Women  Doctors, Brandishing His Gun When He Stormed In Their Meeting, Bomet

    Governor Isaac Rutto Assaults Women Doctors, Brandishing His Gun When He Stormed In Their Meeting, Bomet

    The Governor of Bomet in the company of 30 goons have stormed a doctors meeting at The Fair Hills, Bomet. The Governor and his goons Ā has slapped the Chairman, other Branch officials and kicked and tore clothes of lady doctors.

    The Governor initially had removed his gun pointing at the Doctors to scare and disperse the meeting.

    The Governor has resorted to violence on his own doctors after his media propaganda fell flat on the the public.

    KMPDU officials have now vowed to take very strong action to have the Governor account for his intolerance and violence.

    Intimidation will not implement the CBA. But no amount of intimidation will stop doctors from having the CBA implemented.

    The governor had earlier paraded 3 doctors and signed a deal with them against the rest of the 50 doctors in Bomet who have since continued the strike since they are not party to any deals with the county government and want the CBA implemented in full.

    It’s unfortunate and stupid move coming from one of the presumed sober governors and headliners of devolution empowerment. Instead of using legal channels to address the health crisis, Rutto who shamelessly flew to South Africa to treat a mere bruise to his cheek is busy using unorthodox and violent means to talk down doctors from strikes. Such acts of buffoonery must not only be tolerated but punished. Shame on you Rutto and like that you’re the donkey of the day.

  • Turkana Governor Nanok Battles For Petroleum Bill Be Passed As Residents Stand Missing Out To Dubious Contract

    Turkana Governor Nanok Battles For Petroleum Bill Be Passed As Residents Stand Missing Out To Dubious Contract

     

    Today the Senate will discuss the Petroleum Bill that had earlier been declined by President Uhuru the Petroleum (Exploration, Development, and Production) Bill 2015, would have given local communities 10 percent of oil revenues derived from their areas.

    In a memorandum to Parliament last month, the President instead proposed that the share of profits be reduced to five per cent. The proposal was met with total opposition, and outrage, especially from the County’s Governor Nanok who believes the community deserves an upper hand in the cutting as this, would see the long time marginalized community benefit from proceeds and spring to a middle-level economy.

    Also, while the President retained the allocation of 20 per cent of oil revenues due to a county government in whose region oil is being explored and exploited, he added a rider that it should not exceed twice the amount it has been allocated by Parliament in a financial year.

    Odinga, the opposition leader, is also on record protesting the step by the president declining to assent to the bill as proposed slashing the benefits from 15%-5%. ā€œIn rejecting the Bill, the President proposed drastic changes to the benefits and sharing formula that had been proposed by Parliament. One of the amendments the President wants is to reduce the amount due to host communities from 10 per cent to 5 per cent. The President also intends to reduce the share of County Government from 20 per cent to an ambiguous figure to be determined by the National Government purportedly to cater for what he calls ā€œequitable share of taxes,ā€ whatever that means,ā€ he said.

    ā€œWith that demand on ā€œequal share of taxes,ā€ the President is attempting to place the entitlements of the host communities and the County Governments at the mercy of the executive arm of the National Government. This is a clear violation of the Constitution and an attempt to reintroduce marginalization of communities regarding their resources through the back door, added the ODM leader.

    The Tullow Oil Company discovered about 600M oil barrels which would attract trillions. The discovery has seen vultures stream to cut a piece from the community in unusual steps. The battle for community benefiting had however been left to the Governor and some MPs with Senator of the area John Munyes endorsing the presidential offer. Munyes who’s widely viewed in the county as an enemy of progress is scheming to unseat Governor Nanok. He was recently dumbfounded when challenged to table his table his development track to the community since his tenure as minister for water; Turkana still stands as one of the worst not the county’s with water problems even though devolution has played progressive steps in addressing it.

    Munyes whom we gather from our moles is a dead broke man forced to join Jubilee for funding with DP Ruto being his godfather. It has been a rough and set season for the senator who has since been compelled to shut down his bars and hotels run down by his estranged Ethiopian wife. From Senate records, Munyes is a silent legislator with no bill to his name as term nears the end. One would only wonder what he’d do for the country. Turkana North Constituency that he once represented remains one of the poorest with NSSF grand scam still hanging on his heads; one thing is clear that Munyes is excellent at lip service. As the Bill goes to the Senate will Munyes stand with his people to be the biggest beneficiaries or his allegiance to the Jubilee Government be a barrier and ultimately selling out the community?

  • BEWARE: Shell Involved In Selling Adulterated Fuel, Customers Crying Foul As Losses To The Cartel Run In Millions

    BEWARE: Shell Involved In Selling Adulterated Fuel, Customers Crying Foul As Losses To The Cartel Run In Millions

     

    Oil marketer Vivo Energy, which sells Shell branded products, is locked in a row with its customers after being found to have mixed diesel with kerosene for higher profits. It doesn’t come as a surprise to many as this heinous act that’s showing an insider fraud scheme face, has been in play for long.

    Earlier in the year, ERC listed Shell in their report amongst many petroleum companies involved in the criminal sale of spiked fuel to customers. In a suspicious move, Vivo Energy MD Polycarp Igathe threatened to sue ERC for publishing the business’s name in the exposing list of fraud fuel merchants. Shell is the next in command after Total inKenya’s market share. So Igathe didn’t want the public to know their involvement in the dirty trade that leaves car owners with expensive abs at times irreversible damages to the cars.

    Igathe’s body language towards ERC would be read as a move to cover up the adulterated fuel syndicate which going by the scale himself he can’t feign ignorance on and knowing trends in Kenya he probably in the illegal profit making cartel. Polycarp Igathe, the Vivo managing director, faulted the ERC for naming oil dealers in newspapers after tests exposed 56 petroleum stations for malpractices.
    Mr. Igathe reckoned that the ERC had already punished them including slapping fines on dealers and it was unwarranted to shame the marketers in the newspaper notices. In his defense he said the image of the oil dealer was at stake and could affect business, putting jobs on the line.

    He’s more concerned about the Company’s image than customer’s trust and confidence in the form. If Igathe is genuinely concerned about Shell’s health and reputation then by now he should’ve dealt squarely with the cash-hungry marketers who’ve turned to petroleum adulteration, where diesel or petrol is mixed with cheaper kerosene, which attracts lower taxes, in search of bigger margins. His inaction and cover up threats to ERC are pointing and self-speaking. Petrol attendants are too junior to commission this vast spread scheme. To get a glimpse of this here’s series of complaints from customers who’ve been drugged.

    https://twitter.com/Trackmann/status/808945409322340352

    https://twitter.com/kenyanpundit/status/807862260601389056

    https://twitter.com/tonniemello/status/716227829541769216

    Shell petrol stations are not new to scandals and earlier this year; Vivo Energy was forced to apologize and closed its Ridgeways petrol station where one of its fuel attendants tried to steal a customer’s bank details from the ATM card in what came out as a coordinated cybercrime scheme.

    It all started when an unidentified motorist shared a message on social media, claiming that after giving an attendant the card to swipe, the attendant ran the card under a small machine he was holding under the authorized point of sale (POS) device. The indefinite closure was meant to silence noises abs suspicions that would’ve arisen on other stations.

    With Igathe and Vivo tolerating and not stopping a sale of adulterated fuel the question is why should customers still trust them? Why would me as a motorist put the life of my car in line fueling at Shell with grand suspicions of intoxicating the engine? Customer trust and confidence is everything if Vivo can’t ensure this then looking for cleaner fuel options elsewhere could be my next option and sure any other person who values his car would follow suit. It’s unfortunate that Shell which enjoys market dominance with Total is taking advantage of extensive geographical coverage and traditional customer loyalty to bait them with damaging adulterated fuel. This is unprofessional and unforgivable. Consumers must be protected, and Shell must stop spiking fuel hopefully ERC moves and takes action in such rogue marketers as Vivo Energy. Igathe has failed to maintain a clean face of the old Shell we grew up knowing it’s a shame it has transformed into a fraud outfit under his custody.

  • Doctors Are Human First So Stop With Demonizing And Lipa Kama Tender

    Doctors Are Human First So Stop With Demonizing And Lipa Kama Tender

     

    Kenyan doctors have been in a month-long stretch strike which has escalated into a national health crisis with the government not giving any signs of the positive will to end the crisis that has left poor Kenyans to nothing but God’s mercy.

    The Government given the writings in the wall have decided to turn a complete dead ear on the CBA demands by the Doctors an agreement which the government negotiated with them in 2013. When reality caught up with them to honor the agreement, the government instead resorted to offensive to demonize the Doctors for putting ahead personal demands ahead of calling obligation of their course. This laughable coming at a time when the government is rocked by corruption scandals including the ministry of health. Who’s selfish here? Doctors are simply demanding for what has been negotiated and government inked the deal so what’s wrong in demanding what you rightfully deserve?

    A lot of lies has been peddled around the strike in the desperate bid to exonerate government and dump heap of blames on the Doctors. Here are vital CBA points that we must sink in:

    1) 2011 December, the doctors’ Union (KMPDU) called for a strike citing various challenges in the health sector including but not limited to the working conditions of doctors.

    2) 2011 December a committee was formed chaired by the then Minister for Finance (now our president Uhuru Kenyatta). It was agreed that their grievances were valid. Some concessions were given in the Return to Work Formula with the promise that further discussions between various sectors (Ministry of Health, Public Service Commission, Salary review commission and the union) would work out a longer-term plan that will address human resource issues in the health sector particularly touching on doctors.

    3) After long drawn out discussions in 2013 June, a Collective Bargaining Agreement (CBA) was signed by the then PS for Health (Mr. Mark Bor) and the Union that discussed amongst others, how doctors were graded in the public service scheme, promotions, training, disciplinary actions, grievances, transfers between counties and central government, research fund for enhancing medicine, postgraduate training, internship postings, working hours for doctors, etc. It actions Nelson provided a scheme of service that was a revision of the current one that dates 1994!

    4) Under the labor laws, it is the responsibility of the employer (in this case the Ministry of Health) to file the CBA with the Industrial Court for implementation.

    5) Since 2013, the union has been given the run around by the Ministry of Health regarding them implementation of the legally binding document. The SRC was mandated to advise the Ministry of Health on the proposed salaries from the union. They have never done so. The union also wrote to the Labour Ministry citing the above matters, but no response was received.
    The Public Service Commission in May 2016 also approved the much-needed Scheme of Service for doctors. The Ministry of health to date has never gazetted it.

    6) After much frustration, the union went to court in 2015. One year later October 2016, the court issued a ruling upholding the legality of the CBA. Apparently, the Ministry of health were denying that they were party to it. The court ordered the concerned parties to iron out the contentious issues within 30 days. After the days elapsed without any progress, the SRC requested for an additional 15 days which were granted. The discussions were not held.

    7) In November 2016, the union, under the protection of the constitution (which is above all laws) filed a 21-day notice of a countrywide strike. The notice ended on 4th December 2016. The strike commenced on 5th December 2016 affecting all public health institutions and supported by all doctors irrespective of their workstations.
    The CoG went to court to render the strike illegal. The ruling of this second court bears no weight as the Constitution of Kenya protects and gives the right to go on strike once due process is followed.

    8. The Union will take NOTHING less than the CBA and the Salaries in the CBA MUST be implemented and Backdated from 1/7/2013. And any talks can only be on how to adjust the Figures for INFLATION and LOSS OF TIME.

    The government spokesman Eric Kiraithe is on record saying that Kenya doesn’t need doctors for a man presumed to have functional senses, his utterances dropped jaws. So much nonsense in one joint. The Gov has exhausted all intimidation avenues especially judiciary where arrest threats have been placed on defiant officials to call off The strike.

    Comparing the Doctors pay in Kenya to colleagues elsewhere surrounding leaves so much to wonder. Kenya has been experiencing brain drain because of such a similar mistreatment and exploitation of expertise. In Rwanda which has siphoned on Kenya’s doctors, they’re paying well. Gov we’re told has resorted to importing 2000 doctors to be posted to all referral hospitals across the country to attend to emergency cases. The downgrade doctors supposedly being brought in from China. The body language being the government won’t honor the CBA and ready to strangle the healthcare state to death.

    Kenyan doctors have the option of taking their services elsewhere where their salaries would go up even more than the 300% they’re demanding, but it’s not the government who’ll suffer but Kenyans. The politicians who fly abroad to treat slap bruises would care less about stable healthcare state in Kenya.

    Doctors are human. First, they have families to take care of and bills to pay just like every one of us. When the cost of living goes up, doctors are not exempted so why would we join the Government’s propaganda demonizing doctors for abandoning ‘calling’ in a bid to shut their voices. Calling doesn’t pay bills, good salaries do. The state of healthcare will naturally shine with a motivated doctor. Kenya’s Doctor to patient ratio is so low that the few doctors available are overworked like slaves, and peanut pay is an insult to the injury.

    I call upon the Doctors to stand their ground, and they’re blessed with able officials. History will judge you well; you might not succeed today but tomorrow’s breed of doctors will appreciate the struggles you’ve made. The croaks of frog don’t stop the cow from drinking water from the river. Don’t stop pushing for better pay. Kenya somehow will miss money to pay its workers but never miss money for the corrupt officials to loot. Go for nothing short other than Lipa Kama Tender. They can bring in their plastic doctors from China I doubt they’ll stand the horrible working conditions.

  • With Speaker Justin Muturi And Aden Duale In Parliament, Kenya Is Yet To See The Worst From The Eccentrics

    With Speaker Justin Muturi And Aden Duale In Parliament, Kenya Is Yet To See The Worst From The Eccentrics

     

    Kenya and the world have been treated to the worst of theatrics in parliament during the past days in exceptional settings set to discuss electoral reforms with Jubilee wing rooting for manual back-up of a voting system and opposition insisting on the digital and the negotiated amendments to be sustained.

    The debate as expected was marked with extreme violence with the house turned into a chaotic market with reckless traders. Reports of physical fights between the MPs flew around. And it’s during these sittings that dictatorial smoke signals were sent. The parliament building in a long time since Moi era was completely barricaded and heavy anti-riot police deployed in an apparent intimidation move by the executive who wanted the law passed by all means necessary. Journalists were denied access to Parliament’s media gallery, broadcast signal switched off, internet shut. This a 2017 smoke signal coming at the time when credible suspicions that the government will lock out the internet during next elections, thrives.

    The ugly face of August house with primordial debates presided over by House Speaker Justin Muturi. Muturi has brought the insanity in parliament given his partisan stand and blind sycophancy to the executive. Muturi is a tribal chief placed in a high office. The speaker has brought shame and crashed the credibility and integrity of a powerful institution. Unlike his predecessors as Kaparo and Marende both of whom has political affiliations but kept professionalism ahead by remaining neutral, Muturi like swallowing a whole watermelon fruit is finding it hard to hide his allegiance to political lineage.

    Parliament is an institution that ought to provide social and political unity. However, blind political loyalty and desperation for correctness politics have caused Parliament to serve primarily as a public forum for the ventilation of grievances rather than a law‐making body and unifying institution. Members should have a difference of policy but not trapping the country in the rut of immature and hollow politics.

    Most of his legislative decisions are biased and bring out someone who plays political marionette role. He has significantly eroded the reputation and credibility of the House, lowering the quality of the debate and work of the National Assembly. He poses the threat of returning Parliament to old days of executive control or appendage. Commission on the Implementation of the Constitution (CIC) has gone to court seeking a declaration that Honourable Speaker Muturi is unfit to hold public office.

    The office of Speaker is one of prestige, splendor, and authority. The office of the Speaker occupies a pivotal position in Constitution and instilling culture of constitutional democracy. While the MPs represent the individual constituencies, the Speaker represents the full authority of the House itself. The Speaker symbolizes the dignity and power of the House over which she/he are presiding. Therefore, it is expected that the holder of this office of high dignity has to be one who can represent the House in all its manifestations.

    As long as Muturi retains the seat and Kenya heading to the elections, we’re yet to see the worst as he’ll oversee even the most of crude policies shoved by the executive see the day. Muturi, a once corrupt magistrate, is behaving and talking like someone who didn’t step into a law school. The sooner we get rid of the lunatic, the better Kenya will be placed until then we’re courting disaster.

    Justice Odunga
    Justice Odunga

    Talking of disasters another one in parliament is the leader of Majority Aden Duale who has made a brand of a loose canon, Jubilee’s preferred bark dog given his excellent ability to talk without engaging his senses. Duale is the master of moronic, unintelligent utterances. He even shocks himself on whatever he says. Given the much crap, he talks some unnamed parts of his body must be getting jealous of his mouth. Duale is a preprogrammed bot and a slave to the establishment. As much as we castigate him for unbolted lack of sagacity, we must not forget this is a tragic robot with a developer whom should worry us the most. His owner.

    In one of the most disastrous events, Duale reigned a moronic attack on Justice Odunga accusing him of being tribal and issuing opposition friendly judgments. The law and politics are as distinct as Duale and wisdom something he needs to know. Duale and his masters want a manipulation-prone judiciary something Kenya has worked hard to ride over. Duale is threatening to discuss Odunga when parliament reconvenes.

    This is a direct attack on the independence of the judiciary and the integrity of the distinguished judge and an abuse of parliamentary privilege. It is conducted entirely untenable in any civilized democracy. Justice Odunga holds an important constitutional office as a judge of the superior court and a member of the judiciary whose independence is protected by Article 160(1) of the Constitution. His exercise of judicial authority is undertaken on behalf of the people of the Republic and therefore cannot and should not be subjected to any impediment of any nature.

    With these hired guns seated at the helm of a legislature, Kenya Is cooked and fried waiting to go down the digestive tract. Until wisdom pays them a surprise visit, we must water and soap our hair.

  • Women and Politics, The Frustrations In Sexist Kenya

    Women and Politics, The Frustrations In Sexist Kenya

    The high court has ruled that the Jubilee cabinet is unconstitutional since it doesn’t fully comply with the two third gender rule with under representation of women in The cabinet slots. This is a snippet of the women representation across The board.

    The inclusion of women in politics and public institutions is a process that is necessary but with no easy solutions. A silver bullet approach simply does not cut it. Kenya is ranked amongst countries in Africa with least women representation in parliament. A report by The Africa Human Development Report of 2016 indicates that Africa has four countries in the top 10 with high levels of women representation in parliament. These four countries are; Rwanda, Seychelles, Senegal, and South Africa.

    In the case of Kenya, there is a story behind the lethargy in implementing the gender bill. It is a complicated story that is characterized by the lack of political goodwill and the endorsement of internally induced patriarchal structures evident in the sexist discourse in political spaces. Male members of parliament have been on record for rejecting the gender bill on the rational that this gives room for ā€œpeople to nominate their girlfriends.ā€ The bid to push the gender bill was lost an account of male parliamentarians who argued that the bill was retrogressive to democracy, and that, passing it was tantamount to giving women free seats.

    The vital role of women as equal contributing partners is downplayed by sexist discourse, and this has very direct implications for the number of women who enter these political spaces.

    The fact that Women’s rights to equal representation in the political space and public institutions need to be recognized should not be over emphasized. As it is, Kenya positions itself as a democratic state, yet the truth is that it cannot speak of democracy without having gender democracy. The gender bill needs political goodwill to get through, but more importantly, its enactment and implementation will require male goodwill that reads against the grain of sexist discourse.

    It is important to have men stand in support of women to push this bill through. It is essential that men be part of the change narrative that speaks against sexism and includes more women into the political space and public institutions. One helpful way of achieving democracy is through gender democracy.

    Women representatives in various seats have been targets of sexual assault and preying by their male counterparts who have superiority complex. Moses Kuria one of Jubilee’s irritant legislators who in a scuffle in parliament last year, attempted to undress Mbita MP Millie Odhiambo is now threatening to do the same this time more bizarre. Shebesh was physically assaulted by Kiderothe governor when she went to seek an audience with him over problem faced by constituents. These are examples of tribulations women in office have to go through in the masculine Kenyan politics.

    img_20161221_020555

    Kenyan political scene is murky and gets murkier for the women. As Passaris a Nairobi Gubernatorial Candidate said during Silence is a woman forum where she was the kat panelist to discuss various challenges faced by women, it’s never a walk in the park. “Being a woman in politics has been tough. I get judged by my looks. My project got taken away because it’s a ” boys club.” Said Passaris in her contribution. She continued “A woman always finds the strength to come back again. Women can back other women. Society judges women more harshly.”

    With the gender rule evidently not going through, women need to take the different approach in the fight including vying for the legislative seats. The big man syndrome is in full play and likely factor to demoralize the women. Attempts by Esther Passaris to register her Harambee Party were shut down with the argument that the name was monumental if Uhuru wanted to register a party by the same name do you think he’d be blocked? These are some of the challenges women in politics face. 2017 women must come out in numbers to battle it out with men in the various political seats. This will put them at a good position to push for progressive social policies.

  • Kicking Out NGOs and Introducing Draconian Electoral Laws Are Last Kicks of A Dying Horse

    Kicking Out NGOs and Introducing Draconian Electoral Laws Are Last Kicks of A Dying Horse

     

    By Nicholas Olambo

    As 2017 fast approaches, tactical political realignments are evident. The reality of a united opposition is taking shape by the day, Nasa (National Super Alliance) has chances of being the umbrella under which the opposition will challenge the Jubilee administration.

    Jubilee got into power after twisting the ICC narrative and rallying their huge tribes under what Political Analyst Mutahi Ngunyi described as ā€˜tyranny of numbers.’ Times seem to have changed, and as the political gurus will tell you, you can not be twice lucky in politics. The tyranny of numbers myth has no place in 2017 politics. A united opposition front that ended Mois’s 24-year rule and defeated President Uhuru Kenyatta in 2002 is causing him sleepless nights.

    The president and the entire Jubilee administration is in a panic mode, another term to enjoy eating meat and keep the opposition and Kenyans struggling for the scent is under threat. Loyalists are crossing back into opposition camps, DP William Ruto’s vote-rich backyard is at risk of being sliced by the opposition.
    As these realignments and unofficial campaigns take place, every player is struggling to beat their challengers with the best that they have.

    The government is pushing for amendments to election laws to allow a use of manual techniques should the digital technique fail. The opposition is against the bill and sees this as the ploy to create chances of rigging the 2017 polls. Jubilee boasts of majority membership in both houses, a card they always pull to their advantage and pass draconian laws.

    IEBC on its end has claimed that 10% of the country is not covered by the network, an indication that they may need to manually transmit results from such regions. The manual transmission is liable to ā€˜cooking’ and alteration of results to favor some candidates. This idea is backed by a fallacy that the internet or social media causes violence. The government has already shown intentions of shutting down the internet on election day; the same has been witnessed in other African states under dictators as Congo, Uganda, and Gambia.

    Kenya is sitting on ticking time bomb and a simple mistake to deny the will of the people will blow it. The ruling regimes are kicking out NGOs who are carrying out or financing civic education exercises as being rogue and plotting to finance the opposition and influence the outcome of 2017 polls. Who buys that? So many people in government are splashing out cash from the questionable source to influence the 2017 polls outcome.

    DP William Ruto ā€˜donates’ millions nearly every weekend to ā€˜buy’ the church, The Waigurus of this world looted hundreds of millions if not billions and are now lining up to buy their way into leadership positions. Before kicking out NGOs who are educating the public on the electoral process, a role that the sleeping and ā€˜broke’ IEBC should be playing, deal with the corruption face that is within the executive.

    Crazy as one activist Boniface Mwangi will tell you ā€˜ The government wants you to learn about sex but not electoral processes.’ Provision of ARVs are funded by donors; PSIs are donor funded but not questioned. Whoever will win the 2017 polls should do so based on the manifesto, If the status quo remains, it should be based on track record of the Jubilee administration. So far corruption has rocked the current regime than any other in the history of this nation, and the president has nothing more to do. Jubilee came in ā€˜a digital government,’ what has happened in the short span that the internet now it’s a threat to security? Social media/internet can do more than cheap PR jobs but inform the people.

  • Cheza Games Scam: Safaricom’s Biggest Airtime Theft In Billions And Why You Won’t See This On Mainstream Media

    Cheza Games Scam: Safaricom’s Biggest Airtime Theft In Billions And Why You Won’t See This On Mainstream Media

     

    As we close up to 2017, new cases of scamming just opening up. Safaricom has been rocked by several corruption scandals which they’ve perfectly sailed their ways out given their impeccable PR strategies. While Kenyans are struggling to make ends meet with the ruthless economy, someone has been busy making billions from unsuspecting Kenyans by erroneously subscribing them to a premium service, Cheza Games.

    Since we have a sterile mainstream media gagged with billions in ad revenue from Safaricom who happens to be the biggest source of ad revenue to the Media, at Kenya Insights is the only place you’ll get the gritty details of a scandal that is more significant beyond imagination and surpasses even the NYS heist but no one is talking about it.

    Safaricom is popular for clamping in dissents with courts being their favorite muzzle tool. Cheza Games a premium service linked to Huawei Ltd, a company that has a controversial relationship with Safaricom including their security deal with Safaricom that has been serialized to have been surrounded with monkey dealings.

    Cheza Games illegally accessed Safaricom’s data face and erroneously subscribed customers to the service. Millions of customers were automatically subscribed to this service without their knowledge and approval. This backdoor end subscription went on for long until it was exposed several weeks back on the internet that Safaricom woke from the feigned sleep to admit fraud and subsequently refund affected customers.

    To give just a hint of how big this scam is, Safaricom has an estimate of 25M subscribers; Cheza Games deducts Sh10 every day. In a single day, the fraud quickly makes 250M, and this is not the case, in some instances, customers were deducted up to Sh100 daily which easily translates to 2.5B per day. This scam has been ongoing for months you can do simple math on how much it cost. As if now, it’s estimated that Safaricom has refunded customers up to 6B in airtime over the scam.

    The scheme is cleverly executed in what has insider footprints. There are credible allegations that senior Safaricom managers including staff members have stakes in these third party services. This could well explain how these fraudsters accessed the database and automatically subscribe customers without their authentication from the back end. This is the most probable explanation. Information on the stakeholders of Cheza Games remains scanty with Safaricom being economical with the truth in what is coming out as a cover up the scheme.

    How could such a multi-billion scam to undetected for months, be this deliberate and that management was fully aware? For a company size of Safaricom, it would take a horse to fly to convince me that the management wasn’t aware of this scheme which yet again leaves a heap of garbage at the doors of Safaricom.

    It can easily be concluded that their system security is loosely held that scammers can easily compromise at will or that the management conspired with the Cheza Games owners in the fleecing scheme. Either of the scenarios is again very likely. The speed at which Safaricom’s CEO effected the refunding left more to be desired. Did the conduct investigations or hurried to pay back customers to buy their silence strengthening the belief that Safaricom was aware and part of the airtime fraud.

    cvy156eweaat7yr-768x948

    If determined, Safaricom should be charged for selling consumers data to third parties without their consent a clear breach of privacy. If we’re to believe that Safaricom wasn’t aware of the scheme, then this exposes their lapse in security of their entire system because if one can make billions undetected, then it can be replicated elsewhere.

    Talking of replication, other than Cheza Games scam how many more 3rd party scamming are going on as we speak that’s yet to hit the headlines. The devil is in the details. More fleecing could be going on as Safaricom conducts ‘investigations’. Cheza Games is one example that Safaricom failed in protecting their customers from scammers. They need to have a rigid system.

    There are people who didn’t even have an idea they were subscribed to the Cheza Games until they received refunds notification meaning it was all done in the shadows without deduction notification. This then piles the worries on the existence of such ghostly moving subscriptions.

    https://twitter.com/maumausdaughter/status/810755945710161920

    Things must not end at refunding customers, Safaricom must be seen to be fighting this scam with sincerity, we need to see people in courts, we need to see the employees involved in this conspiracy held accountable and hanged. Until then Safaricom can go ahead with burying the hatchet while the case is still alive. Such scams are costly to the economy. We need an ethical business field with fair play. If Cheza Games scam is let go, then another will come again, and the circle will maintain with customers baring the wrath. There’s no serious consumer protection body to handle plights of customers the one we have is busy with pushing nonsensical hashtags on Twitter daily.

    Cheza Games Scam must never be buried until the full postmortem is done. This must include a top of the iceberg of how third party services is the cash milking cow. With Safaricom’s 100 Customer Care number being ever busy, many consumers have given up making frantic calls to be unsubscribed from the same services and helplessly living with the pain of illegal daily deductions in their airtime daily. I’m talking on behalf of the naive voiceless customer in the village without social media access to scream out their frustrations. The media will downplay the fraud scheme by not talking about it, but Cheza Games and other third party services scam remain one of the biggest scandals to ever hit not only Safaricom but the country and a shame to the corporate space.

    Safaricom is literary holding Kenya’s economy by the balls and a small lapse in their security as Treasury recently warned would lead to an economy shutdown. Mpesa transacts billions daily and in every single economy sector. It’s the dominant money exchange platforms. If Cheza Games managed to compromise Safaricom’s system, you could imagine if same happened to Mpesa. This latest scam casts more questions on the security index of Safaricom and a reason for consumers to worry. At Kenya Insights we’re not taking a backbench position but front to ensure accountability and watchdog for the consumers. To find out whether you have subscribed to some services unknowingly, for prepaid, dial *100*5*4# and post paid, dial *200*5*4#. Choose option ā€œ2ā€ which is ā€œunsubscribeā€. Check you must just meet a new surprise.

  • Is Nakumatt Next In Line After Uchumi As Debt Load Shoots To 18 Billion

    Is Nakumatt Next In Line After Uchumi As Debt Load Shoots To 18 Billion

    Kenya’s largest retailer Nakumatt has been faced with financial tribulations in the recent past with fears that the Group would shut down it’s doors . It’s not only on Uganda that shelves were empty and the firm not running in its all under one roof theme.Empty shelves sent the red signal that financial incapacitating bug had bitten the luxurious chain of stores.

    Nakumatt has now been accorded a credit rating downgrade following a spike in debt level pointing to an increasingly uneasy retail market.

    South African Global Credit Ratings (GCR) downgraded Nakumatt long-term rating to BB- from BB indicating a weakened ability to meet outstanding financial obligations.

    The rating downgrade reflects the notable deterioration in Nakumatt’s credit risk profile. Growth of the business has been highly leveraged, with the ever-growing working capital and capex requirements having been largely funded through short-term debt.

    The rating agency noted that Nakumatt debt burden had quadrupled in the last four years to Sh18 billion up from Sh4.7 in 2012 ā€œplacing unduly high pressure on the group’s gearing and liquidity position, with funding limits having largely been reached.ā€

    Bad debts led to collapse of Uchumi which as of now waiting for a 500M reprieve from the government to restore operations . Nakumatt is admitting cash crunch and attributes the hurdle to harsh economic factors reigning in the region . The Shah family own the majority stakes and previously with Harun Mwau who gave up his stakes to create space for a foreign investor who remains the oxygen that the ailing store so much needs or we’re soon seeing closed doors and that would be unfortunate to one of the biggest chain store not only in Kenya but EA region. There are rumours in business corridors that Mwau gave up his stake and coukd be eyeing gaining shares in Uchumi which has consistently been killed by gross mismanagement of funds by rogue managers.

    Nakumatt you need it, we’ve got it could as well be you need it we don’t have it. That’s if things remain constant.

  • 2017 Storm Brewing, Is Kenya Ready

    2017 Storm Brewing, Is Kenya Ready

     

    Campaigns for 2017 General Elections have unofficially been kicked off with political train gaining momentum by the day. Jubilee aŕe on massive development projects launching across the country and with the timing months to the election, they’re capitalizing on this loophole to score political points.

    The opposition, on the other hand, is witnessing political realignment with a mission of having a united opposition capable of sending Jubilee home in the same taste that Rainbow Alliance ganged up to end Moi’s 24-year rule.

    Jubilee regime has been rocked with significant corruption dealings painting it as one of the most corrupt governments of the four that Kenya has had. Human rights violations as extrajudicial killings that have snatched many lives have also headlined the administration.

    Perhaps the most outstanding are the systematic clampdown on freedom of press and expression. In the last years of Jubilee regime, press freedom has been lowered in an index with draconian laws meant to muzzle information flow. The government has been critical of the media alleging they’re misreporting painting it as corrupt which in the real sense is the truth.

    A Nation Media Group journalist was in trouble on exposing a scandal in tendering at the Interior Ministry. What followed is evident. They came up with another clamping law that required journalists to give evidence on corruption. The President and deputy are on record calling out the media on several occasions as useless reducing newspapers to mere meat wrappers.

    The government hasn’t been soft on investigative journalists and bloggers many of whom have faced their wrath. Recently, a British journalist to The London’s Time was deported under unclear circumstances reports now indicating he was probing the Eurobond case that allegedly cost taxpayers billions spent in nonexistent projects.

    The targeting of media by the regime has exposed their dictatorial motives an indirect attack to freedom of speech and press which are vital in a progressive and democratized nation as Kenya.

    Under the four years that Jubilee have been in power, we’ve witnessed extreme public funds looting like never before. Some of these people are new to this corrupt money which then directs me to the fears that Jubilee might not let go power that quickly. Four years wouldn’t be enough they’ll probably fight to last blood drop to retain power for another five years to finish up work (read looting) started. I have certain key points that are red flags as we move close to the polls.

    ICC

    There has been a sustained campaign to pull Kenya out of the Rome Statute. Like many of Africa’s dictatorial regimes have been yapping that the court is a political establishment targeting Africa, but they don’t tell you that it’s Africa’s leaders who reign more terror on their citizens. The fear of ICC contributed mostly in taming possible violence in the last election in Kenya. Imagine a scenario without ICC and no fear over facing international justice. Gambia’s President who’s now refusing to let go power after the huge loss at the same time preparing grounds for the serious clash in the country hurried to pull his country out of ICC months to the election. They only want ICC out if the way to reign terror in citizens without limitations. The cosmetic sovereignty calls are like music to dead ear. Sovereignty while Africa governments run on donor money.

    Civil Society

    If you’ve been keen, the CSOs have been Jubilee’s top enemies. This is mainly contributed by the active participation of the CSOs on the ICC cases that had President and Deputy dragged to the Hague. It’s their belief that the cases were coined by the Civil Society whom they’ve branded as the evil society despite the fact that most of the CSOs items in ICC were drawn from the State’s intelligence agencies.

    On Jamhuri day celebrations, the president gave the biggest hint that the Civil Society is under attack with the possible shutdown of many. The President accused the CSO for working with foreign powers to change the regime. Ironically the president telling off foreign powers from influencing elections yet IEBC conducting the elections is funded by the Western countries don’t even go to the security dockets and all.

    The mood in the country and hostility towards Jubilee has been frustrating the son of Jomo now issuing warnings everywhere. It’s also not a coincidence that Civil Society has been removed from devolution to interior ministry under colonialist Nkaissery. This is a strategic plan to control and muzzle the CSO as elections nears. The NGOs play the major role in voters education and empowerment. With a weakened Civil Society, Jubilee will have a field day with atrocities which when you look at how police have handled protests in recent cases should worry you.

    Social Media

    There are credible fears that Jubilee would shut down the internet in the same style that has been replicating in most African countries. From Uganda to Gambia and now Congo shutting down the internet as Kabila plots to forcefully extend his term and fears of violence eruption.

    The fallacy that social media causes violence is not only pathetic and primitive thinking but an insult to civilization. Other day a pseudo-journalist, a self, imposed presidential reporter with the Star opened his mouth ahead of his brains calling for social media shutdown over irresponsible posts. This a journalist mark you who should be advocating for the free press and speech. But let’s spare the man as he comes to terms with the fact that his friends have been helping in taking care of his wife.

    Jubilee should have least worry with the internet and work towards giving a credible election that will be the sure way. Kenya is a time bomb waiting for a single wrong movement, and things will go wrong. Shutting down the internet would cause a revolt, it will send out a signal that some fraud scheme is in the oven even if it’s not the case.

    Social Media has a therapeutic effect in that people will vent online instead of picking weapons and slashing each other. It’s not an expensive way to deal with the situation. The keyboards will take away the anger. But the most important thing is to have open, credible elections. Don’t disrupt the peace. Whoever is advising Jubilee to shut down the internet should ask themselves if past poll violence happened because of social media. Free advice, focus on the vernacular radio stations which are dangerous tribal fueling agents, a clampdown on loose cannons the bark dogs of politicians the war mongers, fraud electoral officers. Leave social media alone and for the millionth time, conduct credible, open, Free and fair elections and won’t have to worry for a great poll results from reception. The way Jubilee has invested on anti-riot police in recent times is a story for another day.

  • Miguna: The Elections Will Not Be A Selection Process Of Picking The Best Clown, Machiavellian Opportunist Or Karl Marx’s Clone (A Rebuttal)

    Miguna: The Elections Will Not Be A Selection Process Of Picking The Best Clown, Machiavellian Opportunist Or Karl Marx’s Clone (A Rebuttal)

     

    It’s self-evident that Daisy Maritim-Maina is conflicted.

    She claims that she is part of my movement against the cartels and admits, grudgingly, that I’m the best candidate for the position of governor of Nairobi.

    She correctly acknowledges that all my opponents are ā€œa basket of deplorablesā€ – a cocktail of thieves, plunderers, hypocrites and drug peddlers. However, she has not written a single line excoriating the Nairobi cartels.

    Instead, Ms. Maritim-Maina has engaged in magnificent logical contortions and ploughed acres of space with her poisoned pen transfixed on the general leading a revolutionary movement to clean up Nairobi.

    She states – without any shred of evidence – that I will not win. She seems pleased with her baseless prediction without realising that it sharply contradicts her assertion of being a member of my revolutionary movement.

    It’s a shame that reason and logic are clearly not one of the strengths of this supposed ā€œPhD Candidate in Political Economy!ā€

    When a student of politics on the verge of being bestowed with a terminal academic degree argues in such a meandering manner, sensible citizens should be extremely worried. Logic is, after all, the pith and substance of academic disputations.

    In elegant parlance, Daisy Maina’s inconsistencies may be termed unmeritorious. But in plain language, they are called transparent lies.

    Why is Daisy duplicitous?

    Why does she sound happy that the transformative vision I’ve outlined in my manifesto such as an integrated modern solid waste management system; a modern Light Rail Transit System; a Subway/Underground System; affordable housing for the poor; markets for hawkers; well-constructed roads; scholarships for bright students; and an unprecedented employment initiative for the youth will not be realised if I do not win as she has cynically predicted?

    Why, indeed, are elites like Daisy Maritim Maina happy with the status quo that has plundered, exploited and impoverished Kenyans for the last 55 years?

    Why do Kenyan elites feel more threatened by the visionary transformation I propose rather than the current plunder that has rendered more than 90 per cent of Kenyans destitute?

    Are hypocritical Kenyan elites fearful that a cleaned up and transformed governance system will eliminate fraudulent contracts that they have thrived on for 55 years?

    Ms. Maritim-Maina argues that an unemployed but well-dressed graduate who only recently got placed as an intern – not gainfully employed – is not poor.

    The idea that the type of dress one wears determines his/her economic/financial security or independence is a primitive socio-economic poverty index. This unedifying third-worldview was dramatically displayed when the billionaire Facebook Founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg visited Kenya a few months ago and wore a pair of $45 jeans and $20 T-shirt but the struggling Kenyan hasslers that chaperoned him around Nairobi were clothed in expensive looking attire.

    Yes; I’m not Karl Marx, Frederick Engels, Fidel Castro, Che Guevara or Amilcar Cabral. I’m not a revolutionary clone. I’ve never identified myself as any of these revolutionaries except as one of their loyal and committed soldiers.

    Daisy argues that because I was physically attacked in Kisumu by a mob who had not read the book they claimed they were aggrieved by, I’m not a revolutionary. Set aside the issue of Daisy’s obvious confusion over the sequence and details of the incidents she purports to be writing about. One thing is crystal clear: I’ve never run away from opportunistic attacks whether they are physical or pseudo intellectual.

    She derisively called my memoirs ā€œa book of secrets.ā€ The only ā€œBook of Secretsā€ I know of is the celebrated novel by my friend MG Vassanji.

    Facts are stubborn and no one is entitled to their set of facts. Che, Cabral, Patrice Lumumba, Samora Machell and Thomas Sankara were not just physically attacked worse than I had been; they were brutally assassinated by the enemies of our people. Even Fidel was repeatedly attacked, jailed and tortured before his forces triumphed in 1959.

    One does not cease being a revolutionary because s/he has been physically molested, harassed, defamed, scandalised or murdered. Being physically attacked by misguided mobs is not a sign of the victim’s weakness. It’s a sign of the mob’s mortal fear of the person they are attacking. Weak people are ignored.

    Although I’ve never called myself ā€œEl Commandante;ā€ the title isn’t reserved for anyone.

    I’ll not publish PR images with starving children in slums for me to prove my revolutionary bona fides.

    When a supposed PhD candidate argues the way Daisy does, it exemplifies the fact that it’s not just our politics that requires urgent reconstruction; our educational system, too, needs a CPR.

    The 2017 general elections will not be a selection process of picking the best clown, Machiavellian opportunist or Karl Marx clone. It will be an election!

    Present coherent arguments based on facts against my ideology, vision, policies and programs.

    The cartels constitute less than 1% of Nairobi’s population. I’ll win with the support of more than 99% of ordinary Nairobians who are sick and tired of the kind of excuses Daisy gives for the continuation of the plunder of public assets by the basket of deplorables.
    ____________________________________________________
    Mr. Miguna Miguna is a Candidate for Governor for Nairobi County in 2017. He is a lawyer and author.

     

    This article expresses the author’s opinion only. The views and opinions expressed here do not necessarily represent those of Kenya Insights or its Editors. We welcome opinion and views on topical issues. Email: [email protected]

  • Fears Confirmed: Chase Bank Insider Fraud Scheme Exposed Further

    Fears Confirmed: Chase Bank Insider Fraud Scheme Exposed Further

    As we illustrated in our initial revelation of a yet another Chase Bank Insider Fraud SchemeĀ a lot has happened under the few hours that Kenya Insights broke the story going further to confirm the worst of many fears that the bank in actively engaging in unethical business dealing targeting customers who take loans with them.

    In an instance that we categorically elaborated , a customer who had paid her monthly instalments without default had her loan item repossesed in a clear fraud scheme that bank agents work with auctioneers to frustrate their borrowers inflicting them with the pain of incurring extra charges through their fraud scheme.

    Loan agreements stipulates that an item can only be repossessed when the borrower defaults the terms. This is the loophole rogue agents at the bandaged bank are banking on by forcing a defaulting situation. In this case October’s settlement was paid in September through RTGS as of the bank’s directive but they instead credited a different account belonging to the same customers in a deliberate step to create a loan default.

    Many sympathizers with the bank jumped into their defense saying the borrower has defaulted the loan and that the campaign highlighting the scheme was malicious , Chase Bank stupidly enough , Ā engaged misinformed and pre programmed on hire bloggers to come online to discredit the unchallenged evidence that Kenya Insights tabled. Talk about stooping beyond low.

    The bank’s management knew better that in such a situation the best is to closely monitor the case, find the responsible managers in the scheme and take necessary action instead of engaging in juvenile crisis management that again exposed vulnerabilities and knowledge of the wider scheme.

    It didn’t come as a surprise that the customer whose case was used to expose the scheme received urgent communication from the bank’s top management with immediate instructions to the auctioneer to release their held tractor. Now listen, the tractor which was being held supposedly over loan default which was created by the fraud managers, was promptly returned to the customer and the bank went further to cover all the storage expenses , suspicious much ? Ā So it had to take Kenya Insights highlighting the story for the bank to realize they were holding an item illegally ? If the customer genuinely defaulted loan you bet right the bank wouldn’t have for any reason released it but go through all legal process . The induced release goes to confirm that indeed this is a larger fraud scheme that’s going on in the bank and you can be sure it’s not only at Chase Bank .

    c360_2016-12-15-07-56-16-116

    What should worry Chase Bank customers is not this particular case but a high possibility that this fraud scheme could be in wider play , a major crisis and an alarm to borrowers. How many cases of such harassment and thievery go unreported ? Think about that Chase Bank customer deep in some remote area without a voice without any channel to air their grievance and only buying the word of his banker who in this case happens to the the robber . How many millions are customers losing to such schemes with managers eating off the mysteries of their own trusting customers.

    Chase Bank has a lot as far asregaining stability is concerned and it’s hurting that the bit of trust that it’s hanging on, conniving directors are crushing the crushed glasses of trust they once had in the bank . Central Bank an the Bankers Association need to seriously deal with such schemes that are contributing to more dwindling of confidence in the ailing Kenyan Banking system.

    The last time Chase Bank collapsed the management was quick to put blames on the social media pulling focus from the real situation which was the directors who through insider fraud schemes looted and crippled the bank. Our work is to expose frauds that at the end cost innocent customers. Chase Bank management must come out to give customers sureties and punishing involved managers but until then, potential and existing borrowers have genuine issues to worry about and even reconsider taking loans from the bank which as of now has scared away potential bidders who wanted to take over the bank running under KCB management . Not again shall Insider Fraud schemes go unreported as we will do so at the earliest stages detected to prevent customers from getting a surprise.

  • Panic Grips NTV’s Larry Madowo As He Rushes To Court To Block Eminent Jailing In Case Againt Cyprian Nyakundi

    Panic Grips NTV’s Larry Madowo As He Rushes To Court To Block Eminent Jailing In Case Againt Cyprian Nyakundi

    The Trend’s Larry Madowo is a man living in panic following court verdict that could see him sent behind bars after the 16th Dec hearing or hefty fine on a defamation case lodged against himby blogger Cyprian Nyakundi.

    The fierce battle between the two started way back last year when in his blog, Madowo accused Nyakundi of having attempted to extort 50M from Bidco, a company the blogger had extensively exposed it’s atrocities especially in Uganda where palm tree farmers were displaced under land grabbing circumstances by the Vimal Shah’s owned company.

    What started as tweet battle has escalated into a huge trouble for the journalist who has not only and desperately failed to ascertain the claims he made against Nyakundi on the blog but the company he was defending in his article has since been red flagged by UNDP following investigation results that showed Bidco was extensively involved in serious industrial and human rights violations in Uganda . The same issues that the blogger wrote about have been affirmed by UNDP investigations going further step to discredit Madowo’s ink while the blogger walks exonerated.

    A court in Nairobi has passed a judgment that Madowo faced civil jail or fine in a ruling that is due later this month on the 16th. Knowing the seriousness it comes with, Madowo has rushed to the court to appeal the decision made that has thrown him out of frying pan all the way deep into the fire bed.

    img-20161213-wa0013 img-20161213-wa0012

    Madowo’s predicaments are self made and a result of hear say journalism that has engulfed the journalism field in Kenya . With a big platform as NMG, it’s only professional and responsible for journalists to do proper background on stories before they write to avoid such avoidable law suits . Behind keyboard journalism is costly and had seen the rise of fake news by barely baked journalists churning gibberish news to the consumers. As a whip on yellow journalism and journalists for hire , the courts should deal a major blow to the journalist hopefully .

  • Revealed: New Chase Bank Insider Dealing Scam That Should Worry Customers

    Revealed: New Chase Bank Insider Dealing Scam That Should Worry Customers

    Chase Bank was put Ā under receivership in April sending panic amongst many clients who had cash locked in the bank. Customers were taken through endless financial and mental torture in the period that the bank was closed down by the Central Bank of Kenya .

    As it would later come clear , insider dealings by rogue bank executives including unsecured loans in hundreds of millions led to the untimely collapse of a then fast rising bank in Kenya. The bank directors like in most of corrupt cases were drugged through the judicial system in an orchestrated pattern but nothing heavy reigned on them . As I type this, many of them are enjoying the loot from the corporate thievery.

    Kenya Commercial Bank came as a saviour to the Chase Bank customers by taking over its operation under receivership . Numerous investors had expressed interest in buying the floppy bank but things have changedovertime .

    Kenya’s Central Bank is considering alternatives to recapitalise the troubled Chase Bank after potential buyers opted out of investing in the mid-sized lender that is currently under receivership.

    The Central Bank confirmed that some potential investors dropped their bids, but they remained optimistic that the proposed capital injection into Chase Bank would be completed during the first three months of 2017.

    The banking regulator said it was considering converting some deposits and loans into equity and giving the existing shareholders a chance to buy into the bank.

    While Chase Bank troubles don’t seem to hit any end , Kenya Insights has unearthed yet another fraud scheme within the bank that should not only worry the customers but potential investors as they’ll risk their money taking over a bank marred with scandals and deflated consumer confidence which is an hazardous combination to such an institutions existence.

    In our investigations and we will illustrate with a particular yet common case, ChaseBank agents are working with auctioneers to defraud unsuspecting and naive customers who took loans from them. The scheme is to feign loan default in a systematic plot that even those customers who pay their loans in time and up having their items repossessed . The scheme is meant to benefit the bank agents and the auctioneer companies through damages charges which then they share the loot.

    In this particular case studied by our senior investigative writer , a Chase BankĀ client had a hire purchase facility and which is being liquidated in monthly instalments.

    On the 24/11/2016, the clients tractor was forcefully seized by Igare Auctioneers on ChaseBank’s Ā instructions. The said seizure was illegal and wrongful for the following reasons.

    (a) The client on the 16/10/2016 instructed ECO Bank to pay through RTGS the sum of Kshs.250,000/= to the client’s account (Sakami Ranches Ltd). That money was to clear the October instalment.

    img-20161211-wa0012
    Despite the money having been received by Chase bank,they credited the same to a different account belonging to the same customer, this is a deliberate mistake , contrary to the RTGS instruction. The bank never advised the client Ā that it had credited her account with the said payment. Possibly that was done deliberately, with a view to create work for M/S Igare Auctioneers, and load his charges plus the bank further charges and penalties to the client’s account!

    Even as the client paid the November instalment, it had no idea that as per Chase Bank’s records, the October instalment had not been paid. The sum of Kshs.11,661.70 got loaded into the client’s account, over the non payment of the October instalment.

    (b) A letter dated 2/11/2016 addressed to the client’s directors by Chase Ā bank, was possibly never posted. The letter was advising the Ā client that the sum of Kshs.482,643.20 was due.The bank mark you have the clients email address, and it could have been so easy to reach her. Even on telephone. She only came to learn of that letter on 24/11/2016. Once again, one can only read an intention to create work for Igare Auctioneers and further penalties.

    c360_2016-12-13-07-40-07-093

    (c) It was on the 24/11/2016 when the client’s director was at Chase bank, that she was called and informed of auctioneers in the farm. Upon enquiring why that was being done, she was informed of arrears of Kshs.282.700/=. She was now given a copy of the letter of 2/11/2016. She also learnt that the sum of Kshs.250,000/= paid from ECO bank, was never credited to the correct account.

    (d) She immediately Ā paid the sum of Kshs.282,700/= immediately.

    Upon getting to the farm, she availed the payment slip to the auctioneers, but who still proceeded to seize the tractor. Possibly with an aim of increasing costs and penalties!

    As you can read from the pattern of events , everything seem to be planned to the letter and nothing however legal cab stop it. This is not an isolated case as the writer of this piece managed to talk to three more clients having the same set of problem.

    It’s stressful that rogue Chase Bank directors are taking advantage and baiting naive customers to make few bucks illegally from such dealings . You can do the math how many millions on daily are made from the illegal repossession of items and the mental beatings several clients are forced to undergo.

    It’s such selfish interests and greed that succumbed Chase Bank despite it’s promising future . The bank has managed to record shockingly steady deposits after being put inreceivership and this can only be attributed to consumer confidence . Customers can’t afford to be bitten twice should they discover that the same insider fraud scheme that drowned their savings are back in play .

    Bank can’t survive without customers taking loans as they feed on the interests , who then will take a loan from a bsbk that’s baiting them for disaster .Central Bank governor Njoroge must spring into action before the cartel maul thelittle peace of meat that’s keeping the ailing bank alive . Kenya Insights is committed to exposing all mannerisms of frauds as this of Chase Bank that in long run ends up costly to the consumers .

    This is the time for Chase Bank to regain and maintain customer confidence age not baiting and fleecing from the same wounded customers. KCB as the custodian of the malnutritioned bank must strike a whip on such rogue executives not working to restore consumer confidence in the bank . As things stand, consumers should treat their transactions with the bank with absolute precautions as the predators seemingly not out of the counters. For a bank that operates under relationship theme, the bank is in a troubled relationship with it’s trusting customers , what a waste!

  • Part 1 of 5: How Crooked Mike Njeru With His Company Transcend Media Bullied Safaricom After Tender Disqualification

    Part 1 of 5: How Crooked Mike Njeru With His Company Transcend Media Bullied Safaricom After Tender Disqualification

    Transcend is very bitter over the loss in January 2014 of a tender for Safaricom’s lucrative advertising contract to Scanad, despite Transcend having topped the technical evaluation.

    Safaricom was apparently concerned that Transcend came with political baggage that could damage East Africa’s most profitable company.

    Njeru is allegedly one of the brokers behind the alleged payment of Sh200 million to Justice Philip Tunoi.

    Tunoi had been accused of taking the bribe to influence a Supreme Court judgment on Ferdinand Waititu’s appeal to annul Evans Kidero’s election as Nairobi Governor.

    In February, Saracen won a contract from Safaricom to handle youth advertising, beating Transcend and other agencies.

    In April, Saracen recruited four staff from Transcend. This seems to have precipitated the raid over alleged breach of copyright.

    Transcend possibly believed Saracen had received creative ideas used in their pitch for the Safaricom business.

    But Saracen managers insist they ensured none of Transcend’s original content was brought by the new staff.

    Transcend does not like losing. In 2013 the company lost a Kenya Airports Authority contract and went to the PPOA to protest.

    According to the mobile telco, the marketing department crafted the overarching theme of ā€˜Success is not conventional’ targeting the youth segment.

    In September 2015, Safaricom invited several research companies for a brainstorm and further refining of the concept, with the companies requested to send their submissions in relation to the brief.

    The process saw Youth Dynamix (YDX) identified as Safaricom’s youth research partner.

    Safaricom then briefed its agency Scanad to develop the creative work and craft communication assets, but due to the scope and scale of the BLAZE campaign, the telco company decided to engage a second creative digital agency to specifically handle BLAZE.

    Among the agencies asked by Safaricom to bid and pitch for the handling of the Blaze campaign included Transcend Media, Express DDB, Seven Brands, Media Edge Interactive, Brainwave Communications, Nuturn Limited, Fox 2P Advertising and eventual winners, Seracen Media Kenya.

    In its court filing Transcend says there are similarities between its presentation and the final BLAZE campaign content, essentially accusing Safaricom of lifting and using sections of the pitch by Transcend.

    But Safaricom says the brief sent to the shortlisted agencies had a broad, cross-cutting theme aimed for the ā€˜Youth and discerning professionals segments.’

    The brief, Safaricom says, contained details of consumer segmentation and the brand guidelines outlining the scope and expected standards of the pitch.

    Safaricom says while Transcend ranked very well in terms of creativity, the agency failed to demonstrate the centrality of a digital strategy, a factor Safaricom had underpinned in the initial stages.

    But in what might be the decisive action to lock out Transcend, Safaricom considered the agency ranked very low in terms of ethics and in breach of the Safaricom’s code of conduct.