Tag: Anti-Corruption Court Judge Esther Maina

  • State Recovers Millions From Businessman Who Stole From Mandera County

    State Recovers Millions From Businessman Who Stole From Mandera County

    A Mandera businessman has lost Sh43.5 million, fund suspected to have been stolen from Mandera County government through fictitious contracts after the High Court Anti-Corruption Court ruled that the funds were proceeds of crime.

    Anti-Corruption High Court Judge Esther Maina said Ali Abdi Ibrahim failed to explain the source of the millions yet there was evidence that much of it was from the county government.

    “That Sh. 39,647,426 held in Equity Bank Mandera Branch Account in the name of Ali Abdi Ibrahim is proceeds of Crime and hereby forfeited to the state and Sh. 3,857,943 in Equity Bank Mandera Branch Account in the name of Ali Abdi Ibrahim is proceeds of Crime and hereby forfeited to the state”, Judge Maina ruled.

    The court ordered that the millions in the said accounts shall be transferred to the Assets Recovery Agency at Kenya Commercial Bank KICC branch.

    The High Court Anti-Corruption Judge said that she was not persuaded that an order of forfeiture is a violation of Ibrahim’s right to property guaranteed in Article 49 of the Constitution and that the investigations were carried out by a police officer is also in my view immaterial.

    “Accordingly, the application dated July 23,2020 succeeds, and I enter judgement for the application against the Ali Abdi Ibrahim”, said the Judge in her decision.

    An analysis by Assets Recovery Agency (ARA) showed that two of the accounts held at Equity Bank, Mandera branch, belonging to Ibrahim, received a total of Sh124,750,000 from the various companies, which were being investigated.

    The funds were later withdrawn or transferred to other accounts in a scheme of money laundering.

    The accounts were frozen in April 2020. ARA flagged them down saying they suspect that the man was laundering money.

    Court issued orders freezing about Sh43.5 million belonging to Ali, suspected to be funds stolen from Mandera county government.

    Justice Daniel Ogembo who was handling the case then issued the orders following an application by Assets Recovery Agency (ARA). The agency filed the application suspecting that the funds were paid by companies being investigated for receiving fraudulent payments from the Mandera county government.

    An analysis by ARA showed that two of the accounts held at Equity Bank, Mandera branch, belonging to Ali Abdi Ibrahim, received a total of Sh124,750,000 from the various companies under investigations. The funds were later withdrawn or transferred to other accounts in a scheme of money laundering.

    Between 2014 and 2020, Ibrahim allegedly made suspicious cash withdrawals and transfers in split transactions to evade the reporting threshold.

    Justice Ogembo granted the orders stopping the withdrawal or transfer of the funds in the two accounts, pending the hearing of the case. One of the accounts hold Sh39.6 million while the other has Sh3.8 million.

    “The bank accounts received suspicious huge cash deposits in Kenya shillings and the funds are suspected to be stolen and or fraudulently acquired from Mandera County Government by the Respondent, his agents or representatives and deceitfully deposited and transferred from the above accounts,” reads an affidavit of Fredrick Musyoki

    The officer said investigations revealed that the cash deposits were unlawfully acquired hence proceeds of crime or that there are reasonable grounds to believe that the accounts are used as conduits of money laundering.

    The officer had on March 20 obtained an order from a magistrate to investigate the two accounts. Musyoki said he later discovered that the payments were made by about seven companies being investigated for receiving funds from Mandera county government.

  • EACC Given Control Over Estate Of Senior Treasury Director Accused Of Unexplained Wealth

    EACC Given Control Over Estate Of Senior Treasury Director Accused Of Unexplained Wealth

    A deputy director of external resources at Treasury has been barred from collecting rent from houses in Matungulu, Machakos County that is being targeted for forfeiture to the government.

    Anti-Corruption Court Judge Esther Maina barred Charles Muia Mutiso from demanding, collecting or receiving monthly rental income from the houses, pending the determination of the case filed by the Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission.

    The Judge also prohibited Mutiso from dealing with funds in three bank accounts held at Absa Bank, Co-operative Bank and KCB Bank.

    In the ruling, the court allowed EACC to appoint a receiver for the collection of the rental income, the management and control of the property known as LR No. Matungulu Sengani/3503.

    The house consists of six units of two bedrooms each. The court further restrained Mutiso, his agents, servants or any other persons from selling, charging or dealing with the property, which property valued at Sh8 million and another parcel in DOnyo Sabuk, valued at Sh3.5 million.

    “An order of injunction is hereby issued restraining Charles Mutiso, his agent and servants from transferring, disposing, wasting or in any other way dealing with motor vehicle Toyota vanguard KCH 393M,” court ordered.

    The court directed Mutiso to surrender the logbook of the said motor vehicle to the EACC within seven days, failure to which the commission shall be at liberty to seize, tow and detain it.

    The Judge ruled that EACC had demonstrated a prima facie case and that it shall suffer irreparable loss which cannot be compensated by an award of damages, if the order was not granted.

    “It is also in the public interest that the assets of the subject matter of the suit be preserved pending hearing and determination of the recovery proceedings,” observed the judge.

    The commission moved to court to restrain Mutiso from dealing, selling or transferring the assets which are under investigations over suspicion that they are proceeds of crime.

    However, Mutiso filed at the High Court seeking for an order allowing him to access and deal with his five parcels of land in Nairobi and Machakos counties.

    He claims that the monies in the bank accounts and the properties were not obtained through corrupt conduct or illegitimately, as alleged by the EACC, adding that he can account how he acquired his wealth.

    Mutiso, the Deputy Director External Resources at The National Treasury is said to have Sh36.7 million deposited in four different bank accounts within five years.

    Two ABSA Group Ltd accounts with Sh23,452,775.65 and Sh5,843,390.35 respectively, Co-operative Bank account with Sh1,932,167.53 and KCB account Sh5,557,735.20, are among accounts being investigated by the anti-graft and ethics agency.

    “Investigations further established a pattern of frequent large cash deposits made mostly through the ATM or the drop box. For instance, in June 2015, he made five cash deposits of Sh400,000 each into his account at Absa Group account amounting to Sh2 million over just few days,” EACC says in a brief on their investigations.

    The anti-graft body raised eyebrows over the cash since the Treasury official earns a monthly net salary of Sh118, 691- which amounts to Sh7.1 million within the period in question.

    Mutiso, the anti-graft body says, has also acquired five properties; three in Nairobi and two within Machakos County.

    All his bank accounts have since been frozen due to what the EACC terms as a “huge disproportion” between his assets and known legitimate income.

    The period in question is between April 2015 and April 2020 when it is alleged “that he amassed wealth through misappropriation and embezzlement of public funds.”

    “Analysis of the flow of funds in his bank accounts revealed that he received numerous unexplained inward remittances, EFTs and cash deposits outside his salary from the National Treasury.”

    Mutiso joined the National Treasury as an Economist in July 2002.

    In the course of his employment, he has served and travelled a total of 50 times to various countries representing Kenya.